A Fair Judgement Needs Both Sides
Kitchen Cabinet Painting ~ Read the Good Reviews and the Bad Ones
Most people read the 5-star reviews first. I get it. That's where the happy customers are, and that's what you want to be — happy with your kitchen.
But if you only read the good ones, you're only getting half the story. And half a story isn't a fair judgement.
Most people feel the same way. One study of 2.5 million reviews found 68% of people trust reviews more when they see a mix of good and bad — a perfect record starts to look suspicious, and a mixed one looks real.

What the good reviews tell you
The good reviews tell you how it ended. The finish looked great. The crew was polite. The place was left clean. That's worth knowing — it's what you're hoping for.
But a good review is written when everything went right. It doesn't tell you what happens when something goes wrong. And something can go wrong on any job. That's the part you really need to know before you hire someone.
What the bad reviews tell you
The bad reviews are where you find out how a company operates. Not the complaint itself — the reply to it.
A complaint tells you something went wrong. The reply tells you what the company does about it. And companies answer in a few different ways.
Some blame the customer. The complaint comes in, and the reply turns it back on the person who made it — as if the customer was the problem. Read that and ask yourself: if something goes wrong on my job, is that how I'll be treated?
Some apologize and explain. They own the choice they made, give the reason for it, and stay polite about it. That's a company you can talk to.
Some just fix it. They come back, make it right, and don't argue about it. A problem fixed fast is worth more than a hundred 5-star reviews.
I read about a painter in eastern Ontario who had a cabinet job go sideways — overspray everywhere, doors redone four times, a 10-day job dragging past two months. The owner admitted the first crew had failed, replaced them, paid for the customer to stay in a hotel while it was fixed, sent the doors to a cabinet company for a proper finish, came out himself to install them, and knocked more than $2,000 off the price. That's what fixing it looks like.
And some deny it or say nothing at all. "That wasn't our job." Or no reply — the review just sits there, unanswered. If a review genuinely isn't legitimate — the person was never a customer — a company can report it to Google and get it taken down. Arguing about it in the reply doesn't take it down. Silence doesn't either.
When there are no bad reviews at all
Some companies have no bad reviews. That doesn't tell you anything either. There's nothing on record that shows what happens when something goes wrong — so the test can't be run. A clean record is nice. It just isn't proof.
Take a painter in Toronto with over 230 Google reviews, every one of them five stars. Nice — but there's nothing on record showing what happens when something goes wrong. Same as a company with eleven five-stars, only bigger.
I've seen it myself. A customer came to us last year. He'd had his cabinets painted by another local company, then he moved and hired us for the new place. The quality wasn't there for him — and he's a retired contractor, so he knows what good work looks like. That one job brought us two referrals. No review told that story. The work did.
I'll be straight with you — on Google, I don't have a bad review right now. Eleven reviews, all five stars. That doesn't prove anything. It just means nothing's gone wrong on record yet. I do have 33 older reviews on HomeStars, but you won't find them — I don't pay for a membership, so the profile doesn't surface. Three of them were bad ones, from years ago, and here's what happened with each one.
The first was a DIY job back in 2011. I sprayed the doors and supplied the tools, the product, and the instructions for the homeowner to finish the boxes himself. He came to us through his sister, who'd used the same program. He didn't use the 4-inch roller — he brushed a fast-drying product onto big frame-and-panel doors, wasn't fast enough, and left brush marks. I went to his home, showed him how to fix it — sand and roll — and he didn't have the patience for it. I offered to do it for him for a price. He didn't want to pay, and left it. His review said "you should see the mess made" — without saying what the mess was. Not one word about the work I actually did. I learned from it, and I go into a lot more detail on that DIY program now.
The second was another DIY job, on a greasy, worn-out kitchen. We cleaned it and followed our methods, and four months later there was some cracking and peeling from the contamination. I picked up the doors, sanded them to bare wood, resprayed them, and had them back within ten days. Two months later a drawer front got water damage from the sink — water sitting in the groove between the frame and the panel. That's wear and tear, beyond my control, and the warranty says so. The customer thought it was my responsibility anyway, and the bad review came from that second problem. The fix on the first one never got mentioned.
The third was six years ago, and it was about hinges, not the finish. When we were taking the doors off I noticed some hinges were failing, and I told the customer. Nothing was said by the customer at the time. When Adam was working on the in Home portion the customer asked Adam about it, Adam said to contact me, and they never did. When I arrived I found out they expected me to have new hinges — that was never part of it. We installed with the old hinges, got paid & two doors' hinges failed after two weeks, and I got a bad review. I offered to come back and install new hinges they'd bought, and they wouldn't let me back in the house — said I was belligerent when I stuck to the facts. They refused any help I offered. The problem was the existing hardware, not the finish.
We at the time didn't sell hardware however Since 2024 we sell/include hinges, but only when we sell you new doors. Our warranty states we're not responsible for your current hardware — we do the best we can with what you have, and we recommend replacement where it's needed.
So don't take my word for it. Ask the people I've worked for. Look at the work up close. And hold me to the standard I just wrote down — if something goes wrong, I'll tell you I'll get it done as best as I can, and I'll follow through.
How we answer
When one of our customers show concern, I tell them I'll get it done as best as I can, and I follow through. And if it didn't work, I admit it. Doing your best and owning it when it fails beats blaming the customer every time.
That's the standard I hold us to. It's also the standard I'd tell anyone to hold any company to.
The check
Read the 1-star and 2-star reviews first — and read the replies to them. Then read the 5-star ones. They both need to be read. That's the only fair way to judge.
It's called Kitchen Cabinet Painting, but we take a college-trained wood finisher's approach.
Our NEW 5-Year No Peel Warranty covers our workmanship, including peeling. Everyday wear-and-tear chips aren't covered — and we'll tell you that straight.
Call (519) 401-3161 or get a quote at https://www.sprayitlikenew.kitchen/kitchen-cabinet-painting-quote
Previously: The Sales Pitch Isn't the Work — https://www.sprayitlikenew.kitchen/post/sales-pitch-vs-the-work





Comments